Microsoft Surface as a desktop replacement - update

I'm still using my Surface now as a full on work computer. All seems to be going very well after three plus weeks of daily use.
 
Here's the new pluses and minuses I've discovered with a little more use
 
Still great
 

• The unit is durable - no marks or scratches yet and I don't have a case
• I'm getting used to the squarer corners and holding this as a landscape tablet
• I don't miss a larger screen and can work on this 8 hours plus without fatigue
• The flash Whitelist "hack" still works to enable flash sites, a work around but better than nothing: XDA developers thread
• Screen does pick up fingerprints but they aren't really visible and easy to clean off
• Clear bright screen, no letter boxing on 16:9 content
• Ability to search, share and access settings from the charms bar in any application trumps Android and IOS - plus you can search other apps from within an app (yes this is useful)

Best apps

• Tuner free MCE (most UK on demand services) created by Martin Millmore at Millisoft
• News Bento - almost like Flipboard
• TVCatchup 
• Still MS Office and Internet Explorer it's why I can work on it!

Needs improvement

• Unit shuts off without warning when the battery hits 5% (a rare occurrence as the battery lasts so long)
• Windows store could be better organised, also Microsoft could be more stringent on approvals - quantity isn't quality and there are lots of duds on there
• Mysterious slow downs occasionally when there aren't loads of apps running (hopefully a future update will solve this)
• Music app crashed when I paused a webinar and returned to it after viewing another app
• Needs to be more media friendly (some .mov videos won't play but strangely work without audio when embedded in PowerPoint - codec issues?)
• No support for airport express but then again my Android has issues with that too)
• Still can't print to my Samsung ML1630W Wi-Fi printer - Please Samsung or Microsoft release a driver

Conclusions so far

The surface is a brilliant work tool - I don't regret foregoing my laptop for one minute. It's light, durable and efficient. Plus, I'll say again - I didn't have to shell out £119 for MS Office which Surface Pro owners do. I don't mind not being able to run legacy desktop applications on the Surface. If I need desktop apps I'll pull out the Lenovo X100e laptop. This is 100% the right device for me with very little compromises.

Microsoft Surface on the road

Is the Surface good for business use?

So, I've taken my Surface out for a road trip which is a business meeting involving showing some emails, pdfs and PowerPoint files to the founder of the company.

I felt clever as I flipped out the stand and placed my Surface on the table. "Wow, that's a neat stand" he remarked as his legless iPad lay flat next to him.

Business commences and there's no more talk of the tech. So how was it?

Good

• Showing Excel and making notes as we went along was easier than on a laptop
• Using swipe gestures to switch between email, PPT, Excel, PDF instead of ALT + TAB
• Smooth and fast
• Good viewing angles and clear enough for both of use to see
• No battery anxiety, so much so that I left the charger at home!

Not so good

• I would have brought my external mouse for Excel edits as I'm finding the Touch Cover clumsy and not as responsive as I'd like - plus I could input without moving the tablet
• Same for my wireless keyboard for Excel edits
• Typing this post on the touch keyboard and still haven't mastered it, slow going

Conclusion
I was able to do everything I needed without too much pain and much preferred bringing the Surface to lugging a laptop about. I still need to learn the best ways to use the device input wise. Do I get a Type keyboard? Carry a rollup wireless one plus a mouse? Depend more on the touch screen?

I have to say that it's really light compared even to 'ultra' and netbooks. You really don't feel you're lugging around such a capable device. Seven hours into the day on 5/8ths brightness and still 38% battery left.

Further updates as I continue to use it.

Who or what is the Microsoft Surface for?

Microsoft Surface RT in "desktop" mode

 

Okay, I got this idea in my head that I should get a Microsoft Surface. A couple of years ago I got rid of my home laptop, a Fujitsu P1510D which happened to be a convertible laptop/tablet with a stylus and resistive touch screen. Needless to say I seldom used the touch functions.

I've long been a fan of ultra portable laptops and have had my share of Toshibas and IBMs. Spending a lot of time on the road and in presentations I have always sought light, powerful laptops with long battery life.

I've just started a new consulting job which entails working from home, lots of travel and potential trips out to India. I toyed with the idea of getting an iPad but knew that it couldn't completely replace a laptop or desktop computer.

Enter the Surface RT. eBay is usually my first port of call for technology, most of my phones, computers and even household items come from eBay as lightly used or repairable. My most recent phone, the Samsung Galaxy Note is an eBay special. It's only a few months old, less than half the new price and I've put it on a £8 tariff with Talk Mobile. Who needs to spend £35+ per month? but I digress, let's get back to the Surface (no pun intended).

I looked at the unit briefly at John Lewis and also compared it to be Samsung Ativ. I didn't know much about Windows RT but a Samsung rep was on hand to assist.

"Does this come with Windows 8 Pro?" I asked. "It comes with Windows but I think you can upgrade it, let me ask the Microsoft rep" she replied. A few moments later she came back and confirmed (incorrectly) that I could upgrade to Windows 8 Pro, that it would be free and come as an update.

I'll spare you the details of the back and forth but suffice it to say that in these instances of confusion, Google is your friend...It simply confirmed what every other reviewer has said; the Microsoft marketing machine has done a poor job of educating people on the subject of Windows RT vs. Windows 8.

The Surface RT 64GB at John Lewis with the touch cover is £559 -  precisely the same price as the iPad 4 64GB. Coincidence? Perhaps. You could argue that the Microsoft is as good value as the iPad because it comes with the keyboard, but then again the iPad has the famous Retina display. So, probably a wash. The critics has said that MS has made a huge error on pricing and they should have undercut the iPad etc. etc.

If it was cheaper they may have gained more market share. But, would that have meant people would hang on to them even if they bought it to run legacy Windows applications and found out they couldn't? Probably not.

Which brings me back to eBay, many received these as gifts at Christmas or bought a Surface without knowing you were limited to installing only what was in the Microsoft store or signed by Microsoft. You could jailbreak to bypass the signing issue but it really doesn't bring huge benefits because of the absence of useful ARM compiled apps.

I found a seller who had parted with the £559 and decided that RT wasn't for him. We negotiated a bargain price of £370 an eye watering loss on his part of almost £200 in two months. It came it its original box AND  it came with a 32GB class 10 micro SD card which would have been around £30. So a loss north of £200 for him and possibly a gain for me.

I could have bought a Core i5 laptop for the same money with many gigs of ram, terabytes of storage and a bigger screen (not touch though). But with that also comes more weight, more heat, more noise and moving parts. So I opted for the surface in the hopes that it could and would serve as a replacement for a normal computer.

So far so good. I'm not going to rave about the Surface nor am I going to slate it. I am going to say that it comes with MS Office Home and Student 2013 which is updated from the preview to a full version via Windows update. This is a great inclusion considering that it would cost £109.95 for the package. By the way, Surface Pro does not come with Office.

Positives:

• You can pick up a nearly new 64GB unit with the touch cover keyboard for £400 or under
• It comes with Office 2013 Home & Student
• The legacy (old) desktop is present and you can work in Windows like on a "normal" computer
• You can access the file system, drives, removable storage, printers as in Windows 7/8
• All day computing on one charge (yes, really)
• Runs cool
• Fast enough for office work
• Very portable and you don't have to lug your laptop everywhere
• Full size USB port
• Clear, bright screen, I use this as my desktop and I'm not yearning for an external monitor - beats my Lenovo laptop screen into submission despite being smaller
• Great industrial design - it exudes quality and feels substantial

Not so good:

• It didn't have a driver for my not so old Samsung ML1630W wireless printer and MS support couldn't help
• No Windows Media player
• Would have been nice to play WTV files produced in Media Centre. (I realise only 6% of users ever open Media Centre and only 10% of those actually use it so understand this omission)
• Sure, there are 17,000+ apps in the store but I can assure you most are either useless or seem incomplete (e.g. no messages on the eBay app, no journey planner in National Rail)
• Microsoft should have put their own developers to work so the most popular apps were available at or shortly after launch (e.g. Flipboard)
• Takes some getting used to when using it as a tablet because it's wider than an iPad in landscape mode and the square edges can be uncomfortable

It most definitely isn't a media consumption tablet although you can scrape by if needed. If you're looking for a stellar media experience you're better off sticking to IOS or Android tablets. However, if you're willing to wait it does show promise. News 360 is almost a Flipboard replacement for now. I do use it in the evening for "entertainment" but my Galaxy Note can step in to fill any gaps.

It is however, a suitable replacement for a normal office computer. It's fast enough, light, pleasing to use and comes with Office, a real USB port and expandable storage.

I'll be updating this so stay tuned for more updates. I wouldn't write the Surface off just yet...